*** OVERALL IMPRESSION ***
I am really pleased with this jacket and expect to use it for years to come. I was looking for something mid-weight for fall and early spring, and I think I've found it. Comfortable, warm, good looking, incredibly well made, and surprisingly well-priced. Add some layering and you could wear this through the winter in many climates.

*** FIT & FORM ***
This jacket has an excellent, trim fit. I'm 5'11", 165 lbs, and most of Carhartt's products are cut for my more...rotund brethren. No bulging beer belly here. I ordered a medium and it fits well with room for some layering. The back has some pleats so you have a full range of motion. Really good pockets; the main outer ones are at the right height for your hands, and the angle ensures stuff won't fall out. The zippered breast pocket is a must. Inside, there are two good sized pockets, one zippered, one velcro. The cuffs are fantastic - elastic inside keeps out the wind and weather, but the sleeve extends over it. This does two things: (i) insulated gloves will fit over the elastic but under the sleeve, improving the seal, and (ii) it looks better than just plain elastic. That, combined with the straight bottom makes for a much cleaner, 'stylish' design.

*** MATERIAL & CONSTRUCTION ***
This is typical Carhartt construction. If you've bought their stuff before, you know what I mean. If you haven't, that roughly translates to 'build like a tank'. You could wear this thing on job sites for years before it would be any worse for the wear. It's double- or triple-stitched where it needs it. Tough, rugged exterior (although this 'sandstone duck' is softer and less restrictive than their normal heavy canvas) will block the wind. A little waterproofing spray will help keep off the rain and snow. The fleece-like liner is cozy and warm. Solid, heavy zippers won't crap out on you.