So I ordered a 2XL Tall in black because I ordered a 2XLTall in charcoal last month and it fit as expected. I tried on the sizes at a local store then just bought the tall version here.

This is a good product and I've always liked these, however these do shed fluff right out of the box so be careful if you wear it over another shirt initially, it will most likely coat that shirt with fluff. Which isn't the end of the world, but when you're at work and you wore a light blue button up, taking off the flees only to find fluff ALL over you end up stuck wearing this all day.. Which can get hot.. Which is irritating. But whatever a couple of washes ad it should be good.

Back to the sizing issue. I found that the black was made in Haiti and the charcoal in Sri Lanka. There may be a communication issue between manufacturing locations that caused the disparity. The charcoal fit as expected, however the black was small. I placed them both next to each other to compare. It looks like the length of the arms and height of the fleece are very comparable between the two, however the width is noticeably different. I would say the black was a XL Tall not a 2XL Tall.

Initially I thought about returning it but the 2XL is slightly large on me and the XL is slightly small. A little needed weight loss and the XL will work.

Unfortunately due to the sizing issues or mislabeling, purchasing these may take a certain amount of trial and error.